Friday, October 16, 2009

Monograph #1 Mircea Elide

Christmas, an Aggregate of Archetypes


The theory of Mircea Elide that proposes repetition of an archetype is most well shown in holidays that people commemorate and celebrate. Holiday itself is made by people as they repeated a specific archetype from generation to generation. The Christmas would show us not only repetition of an archetype but also the fact that people make rituals based on something that is related with a divine model.

Christmas is an annual holiday celebrated on December 25 that commemorates the birth of Jesus Christ. This is a popular holiday that is celebrated by both Christians and non-Christians. However, December 25 is not Jesus’ actual date of birth and this day has been chosen to correspond with other holidays that pagans were celebrating. There were many holidays or customs that were corresponded with Christmas.

First one was The Roman solar holiday Dies Natalis Solis Invicti which means “the birthday of unconquered Sun” The use of title Sol Invictus allowed several solar deities to be worshipped collectively, including Elah-Gabal, a Syrian sun god; Sol, the god of Emperor Aurelian; and Mithras, a soldiers' god of Persian origin. Emperor Elagabalus (218–222) introduced the festival, and it reached the height of its popularity under Aurelian, who promoted it as an empire-wide holiday. This day had held no significance in the Roman festive calendar until it was introduced in the third century.

Second one was a winter festival which is the most popular festival of the year in many cultures. Reasons included the fact that less agricultural work needs to be done during the winter, as well as an expectation of better weather as spring approached. Modern Christmas customs include: gift-giving and merrymaking from Roman Saturnalia; greenery, lights, and charity from the Roman New Year; and Yule logs and various foods from Germanic feasts. Pagan Scandinavia celebrated a winter festival called Yule, held in the late December to early January period. As Northern Europe was the last part to Christianize, its pagan traditions had a major influence on Christmas. Scandinavians still call Christmas Jul. In English, the word Yule is synonymous with Christmas, a usage first recorded in 900.

And lastly, Saturn, a god of agriculture and Mitra, a god of sun of Iranians were worshipped at that day by people.

The earliest reference to the celebration of the nativity on December 25 is found in the Chronography of 354, an illuminated manuscript compiled in Rome in 354. In the East, early Christians celebrated the birth of Christ as part of Epiphany (January 6), and this festival included the celebration of the baptism of Jesus. Christmas was promoted in the Christian East as part of the revival of Catholicism following the death of the pro-Arian Emperor Valens at the Battle of Adrianople in 378. The feast was introduced to Constantinople in 379, and to Antioch in about 380. The feast disappeared after Gregory of Nazianzus resigned as bishop in 381, although it was reintroduced by John Chrysostom in about 400.

Christmas during the Middle Ages was a public festival that includes ivy, holly, and other evergreens. Christmas gift-giving during the Middle Ages was usually between people with legal relationships, such as tenant and landlord.

In modern ages, people all over the world are celebrating and considering it a holiday emphasizing family, goodwill, and compassion as opposed to communal celebration and excess.

In the History and origin of Christmas, it is a noticeable fact that Christmas was associated with various pagan customs. And those customs were all derived from a myth and a divine model. Christmas can be considered as an aggregate of various archetypes derived from a divine being. This Historical analysis on Christmas can offer us an important source to explain Eliade’s view. It also shows that archetypes or ritual can possibly interact with each other.

Christmas is mythical. People are celebrating the birth of Jesus whom they have not ever seen. The fact that God, a divine model has come to the earth in appearance of man is attractive enough to make people interested in it. Their interest and desire toward a divine events or being lead to the ritual, and as many people practiced it, it became an archetype that is repeated even today. And as it is mixed up with other rituals or archetypes derived from mythical or divine events or being, it became a good example to explain how people make their rituals and repeat archetypes and how the different archetypes or ritual interact with each other.

Christmas, undoubtedly a most popular and well known holiday has been celebrated more than 1500 years all over the world regardless of religions, and nationality. It is a typical archetype and a ritual which is derived from a divine being. People are celebrating and repeating the event that has happened 2,000 years ago. We will be able to see how exactly Mircea Eliade pointed out the characteristics of an archetype and a ritual through “Christmas”




Sources:

Christmas. (2009, July 6). In Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved 18:50 July 6, 2009, from http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Christmas&oldid=300514140

The History of Christmas (2009, July 6). Retrieved 19:10 July 6, 2009, from http://www.thehistoryofchristmas.com/christmas_history.htm


Christmas (2009, July 6). Retrieved 19:25 July 6, 2009 from http://enc.daum.net/dic100/viewContents.do?&m=all&articleID=b22k0537a

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Monograph #12 Fernand Braudel

Development of Transportation, Vehicle


Transportation is the movement of people and goods from one location to another. Transport is performed by modes, such as air, rail, road, water, cable, pipeline and space. The field can be divided into infrastructure, vehicles, and operations. (Wikipedia)

As Civilization emerged, and farming and domesticating which resulted in surpluses began, there came trade between groups. What is really important in trade is transportation. In order to trade, people needed to move their goods to trade. This need urged people to seek efficient way of transportation and it was the beginning of development transportation.

Since BC 3500 when the civilizations began, technology and means of transportation has been developing until now. Therefore, I would say the development of transportation would be a good example of events which takes place in long duration time span that Fernand Braudel proposes.

When we talk about transportation, the most of us would first think of vehicle which is a mechanical means of conveyance, a carriage or transport. (Wikipedia) So I would like to focus on how vehicle has been developing in long time of History by following chronicle.


BC 3500

Fixed Wheels on carts are invented – The first wheeled vehicles in History. Other early wheeled vehicles include the chariot.

The wheel is quite great invention in human civilization. The oldest wheel was found in Mesopotamia. We all know that wheel is everywhere on all our cars, trains, airplane, machines, wagon and most factory and farm equipment. We cannot imagine that we move things without wheel. It is so amazing that we, resent people still use a wheel which invented 5,500 years ago.

River boats are invented – Ships with oars

Vehicle was invented not only on land but also on water. In Mesopotamia, the first boats were built out of inflated and stretched animal skins and clay pots. The Egyptians used reeds. Early wood boats included: rafts, canoes, and dugouts.

BC 2000

Horses are domesticated and used for transportation.

Sculptures and drawings that date from the 2nd millennium BC show men and women on horseback. Using Horses as means of transportation played vital role from ancient countries to before a car invented.
181-234

The wheelbarrow is invented.

Chuko Liang (181-234 A.D.) of China is considered to be the inventor of the wheelbarrow. Liang was a general who used the wheelbarrows to transport supplies injured soldiers. The Chinese wheelbarrows had two wheels and required two men to propel and steer.


1492

Leonardo da Vinci first to seriously theorize about flying machines - with over 100 drawings that illustrated his theories on flight

He had over 100 drawings that illustrated his theories on bird and mechanical flight. The drawings illustrated the wings and tails of birds, ideas for man carrying machines, and devices for the testing of wings. The Ornithopter flying machine was never actually created. It was a design that Leonardo da Vinci created to show how man could fly. The modern day helicopter is based on this concept. Leonardo da Vinci's notebooks on flight were reexamined in the 19th century by aviation pioneers.

1620

Cornelis Drebbel invented the first submarine - an human oared submersible

Designs for underwater boats or submarines date back to the 1500s and ideas for underwater travel date back even further. However it was not until the 19th century that the first useful submarines began to appear.


1787

Steamboat was invented

In 1769, the Scotsman James Watt patented an improved version of the steam engine that ushered in the Industrial Revolution. The idea of using steam power to propel boats occurred to inventors soon after the potential of Watt's new engine became known.

1862

Jean Lenoir makes a gasoline engine automobile

Belgian-born engineer, Jean JosephÉtienne Lenoir invented and patented (1860) a double-acting, electric spark-ignition internal combustion engine fueled by coal gas. In 1863, Lenoir attached an improved engine (using petroleum and a primitive carburetor) to a three-wheeled wagon that managed to complete an historic fifty-mile road trip.

1867

First motorcycle invented

American, Sylvester Howard Roper (1823-1896) invented a two-cylinder, steam-engine motorcycle (powered by coal) in 1867. This can be considered the first motorcycle, if you allow your description of a motorcycle to include a steam engine.

1903

The Wright Brothers invent and fly the first engined airplane


Orville Wright (1871-1948) and Wilbur Wright (1867-1912) requested a patent application for a "flying machine" nine months before their successful flight in December 1903, which Orville Wright recorded in his diary.

1926


First liquid propelled rocket launched

Liquid fueled rockets were first theorized by Tsiolkozski in his "Investigation of Interplanetary Space by Means of Reactive Devices," published in 1896. His idea was realized 27 years later when Robert Goddard launched the first liquid fueled rocket.

1947

First supersonic jet flight
Dr. Hans von Ohain and Sir Frank Whittle are both recognized as being the co-inventors of the jet engine. Each worked separately and knew nothing of the other's work. Hans von Ohain is considered the designer of the first operational turbojet engine. Frank Whittle was the first to register a patent for the turbojet engine in 1930. Hans von Ohain was granted a patent for his turbojet engine in 1936. However, Hans von Ohain's jet was the first to fly in 1939. Frank Whittle's jet first flew in in 1941.

1969

First manned mission (Apollo) to the Moon

"That's one small step for [a] man, one giant leap for mankind." Neil A. Armstrong uttered these famous words on July 20, 1969, when the Apollo 11 mission fulfilled Kennedy's challenge by successfully landing Armstrong and Edwin E. "Buzz" Aldrin, Jr. on the Moon. Armstrong dramatically piloted the lunar module to the lunar surface with less than 30 seconds worth of fuel remaining.

1981

Space shuttle launched

After a gap of six years, NASA returned to human spaceflight in 1981, with the advent of the Space Shuttle. The Shuttle's first mission, STS-1, took off on April 12, 1981, demonstrating that it could take off vertically and glide to an unpowered airplane-like landing.



In this quite long duration of time span, we are able to see how the transportation has been developing. The changes in transportation technology were quite gradual and slow but steady. As what we see, technological advancement in transportation brings us even outside the Earth.

Actually, the changes and development of transportation did not occur at once and they do not seem that they were giving great impact every time when each of them took place. However, the development of transportation very much contributed on development of human society and civilization in fact.


Sources:

Transport (September 25, 2009) In Wikipedia. The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved 00:03 September 25, 2009 from
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transport

Vehicle (September 20, 2009) In Wikipedia. The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved 19:16 September 20, 2009 from
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle

Braudel, F. (1982). On history. (S. Matthews, Trans.). University of Chicago. (Original
work published 1969).

The History of Transportation (2009) About.com, a part of The New York Times Company. Retrieved September 25, 2009 from
http://inventors.about.com/library/inventors/bl_history_of_transportation.htm

Position Paper # 12 Fernand Braudel

1


The Three Time Span


Personally, I am quite impressed by Fernand Braudel’s vision on History. I am able to notice that he has quite different view point with other Historians. While other Historians seek significance of some special events which are dramatic and exciting and which took place mostly in a short time, he would like to take a long and wide view on History which focuses on long duration events that are not really exciting and interesting. I am not insisting that his work is way better than any other philosophers of History. Rather I would want to point out the value of his work in establishing unbiased and not narrow view on History.

Danto, who advocates narrative form of account and interpretation of History willingly or unwillingly, focuses more on short-term events (Which Braudel calls History of event) than long duration events. Although Braudel idea challenges Danto’s view, I still admit Danto advocating narrative account because this sort of analysis can give us emphasis and important teachings from certain noticeable events. I believe that Danto’s narrative account and Braudel’s long duration events are the two big pillars required in building up proper and unbiased view on History.

Fernand Braudel is much interested in different types of time span and rhythm. He believes that historians must not only consider the relations of coexisting elements (for example, cultural, geographic, economic and political developments) but also those over different periods of time (for instance, long-term and short-term developments). (Marie Hughes Warrington, 2009) The three types of time span Braudel proposes are: history of event, history of conjucture, and history of Long duration.

First, history of event may be 5 years, 7 years or around 10 years. This time span is suited to the study of things like major events (Staloff, 1995). The sort of events which is noticeable like wars and revolutions take place in relation with individual time span. I would say that individual time span and the events took place during that time span is where the most of narrativists focus on because the events of individual time span are generally absorbed with dramatic development with exciting revelation.

Second, history of conjucture may be measured in decades. The events of social time span generally take place cyclically in 20 to 50 years duration. The sort of events during social time span is generally referring to business cycle, technological development and so on.

Third, and last, history of Long duration which is Braudel is interested in most. It is not measured in decades but in centuries. Ecological, geographical history and rise and fall of civilization are the sort of events which take place in long duration time span. Those changes and developments are extremely slow and gradual.

Braudel uses metaphor in his account on time span. According to him, history of event is surface of the water, history of conjucture is the wave, and history of long duration is the tidal force. What does that imply? The events the most of us and specially narrativist interested in are like surface of water which occurs as a result of movement of wave. And the deeper cause of moving wave is tidal force.

Braudel actually wants to concentrate on Historical events which refer to tidal force rather than surface events. He insists that long duration time span is actually deeper study of History. That is why he sometimes criticizes narrativists like Danto who are generally focusing on surface of History. I believe that his point is that while we are too much focusing on surface of water we might overlook the importance of wave and tidal force which are actually fundamental cause or factor of surface of water.

Braudel wants us to consider the ‘deeper waters’ of the style of history as well as its content and boundaries. (Marie Hughes Warrington, 2009)


2


Braudel’s Structuralism


So what part of History in particular is Braudel interested in? Actually, his study is rarely dealing with dramatic event but structure which exists beneath the surface of events and with the conjuctural comprises what he calls unconscious History. (Staloff, 1995)

Structuralism is defined as a method of analyzing phenomena, as in anthropology, linguistics, psychology, or literature, chiefly characterized by contrasting the elemental structures of the phenomena in a system of binary opposition. We can see structure as a distinct pattern of relationship between persons, institutions and entities within a society. Therefore, I would say Braudel’s study profoundly looks into social changes with regards to the structures.

Braudel is considered as Historian who revolutionized 20th century study of his discipline by considering the effects of such outside disciplines as economics, anthropology, and geography on global History. (Wikipedia) In order to precisely look into the structure of History, Braudel chooses to study economics, anthropology and geography which require wide and long view to study because the events of such studies take place in long duration time span. He believes that once we know deeper level of time (tidal force) then we can with them why we have the wave and surface we see.

I would like to support Braudel’s idea. I strongly believe that Historians must cultivate widened and deepened perspective on History. In order to understand History properly, we must not stay at surface of the sea of History but must go deeper to see waves and tidal force which move the sea of History. Knowing events of long duration time span give us profound and precise understanding of events of short time span. So I would want to say that narrativists need to cultivate their knowledge of long duration event also rather to much focus on the dramatic events in order for them to improve their account of their studies.

I would like to highly value Braudel for pointing out the fact that fundamental causes and factors of the events like wars and revolutions (which are dramatic) which the most of students who study History are mainly dealing with are found in long duration time span that is boring, too ordinary and seeming not important. His idea suggests us to avert our eyes to ordinary people and their lives rather to focus only on dramatic and exciting events. Braudel insists that our lives must be recovered structurally.

Braudel’s idea promises us to recover the experiences of ordinary people and treat their lives as integral part of History. (Staloff, 1995) While Hegel is insisting History that of Great man, Braudel suggests us to look into the ordinary people’s lives and experiences. While Danto and other analytic narrativist are absorbed in dramatic and exciting like surface of the sea which flows fast, Braudel suggests us to look into the events that are not dramatic and exciting but really important like deep water of the sea which flows slow without any sound but which is strong force that is moving whole sea.

For recent people who are pursuing incentive, dramatic and exciting Historical events, Braudel’s theory would be great challenge. His theory helps us to have unbiased and balanced view. He sharply points out what are not really noticeable and we easily pass by without any impression in studying History. I am quite impressed by his work on History.



Sources:

Staloff, D. (1995) The search for a meaningful past philosophies, theories, and
interpretations [Audiobook]. The Teaching Company.

Hegel, G.W.F. (2001). The philosophy of history (J. Sibree, Trans.). Kitchener, Ontario:
Batoche Books.

Danto, A.C. (1985). Narration and knowledge. Columbia University.

Braudel, F. (1982). On history. (S. Matthews, Trans.). University of Chicago. (Original
work published 1969).

Marie Hughes Warrington (2009). 50 Key Thinker on History New York: Routlege

Fernand Braudel (September 25, 2009). In Wikipedia. The Free Encyclopedia Retrieved 18:11 September 25, 2009 from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fernand_Braudel

Monograph # 11 Arthur C. Danto

Gwang-Ju Student Movement


For few years after 3.1 Movement in 1919, there was no such movement against Japan to cry for the nation’s independence. And Japanese colonial policy became harsher than before. In 1920, there was a great depression which swept all over the world. It has resulted as food shortage in Japan. As a way out, Japan increased the quantity of rice she took from Korea, her colony by force. The Japanese policy of hard exploitation brought Koreans to great frustration. Under the frustration, depression and suffering, Koreans were losing their passion and willingness to achieve their nation’s independence. They were too busy to think of the independence of the nation.

Would you believe if it was just an incident of a fight between a 16-year-old Korean boy and a number of Japanese middle school students that set the fire to the movement for nation’s independence once again?

One day, it was October 29, 1929, as usual the school train from Gwang-Ju arrived Na-ju. In the train there were both Korean and Japanese students. When the train arrived to the station, Japanese students Hukuda, Danaka and others ridiculed and did violence to Korean girls, Park Gi-ok and Lee Gwang Chun. Hukuda snatched down Park’s hair and never stopped ridiculing.

Park Jun-Chae, the brother of Park Gi-ok coming into the station saw his sister was being insulted and tried to stop them. But Japanese did not listen to him. Japanese policeman who saw them fighting came to Park Jun-Chae and beat him up with other Japanese there. It was known to other Korean students and group fight between Korean and Japanese students has begun in the station.

It was continued up to November 3, the one of the biggest Japanese national holiday that celebrated birth of Meiji. What was so interesting was that November 3 of 1929 was October 3 in the lunar calendar, the national holiday of Korea that commemorated beginning of Korea. During the commemorative ceremony of Meiji day, Korean students refused to sing Kimigayo, the national hymn of Japan and this once again set fire to fighting between Koreans and Japanese. The group fighting was widened to fighting of all the students in Gwang-Ju region and it was not fighting anymore but a movement of Korea against Japan.

At first, the fighting began with 10-20 people. But later on, the number of people who were involved in the fighting became 500 and again, it became 3000 number of students and citizens participated in the movement

Korean students organized the Student Movement Organization and tried to extend their movement to all the regions in the nation. They also made propaganda movement saying that:

1. Let us recapture our unjustly arrested students.

2. Let us strongly forbid entrance of polices into the schools.

3. Let us abolish colonial educational system.

4. Let us establish up our own educational system

The movements continued until Japan gave up her colonial rule in Korea. In fact, student movement set fire to many of patriot in Korea and brought other movement for independence once again.

The small quarrel between 16 years old Korean boy and other Japanese students just because Japanese insulted Korean girls, brought national movements once again. 24 years later, the government of Korea commemorated the students who fought for their nations by setting November 3 as a Student Independence Movement day. They still remember the students, a young sprit, which brought courage and fire to their nation.



Source:

Gwang-Ju Student Movement Retrieved on 20 September 2009 from
http://kin.naver.com/detail/detail.php?d1id=11&dir_id=110101&docid=3366206&qb=saTB1sfQu/2/7rW/&enc=euc-kr&section=kin&rank=7&sort=0&spq=0

Gwang-Ju Students’ Independence Movement Retrieved on 20 September 2009 from
http://kin.naver.com/detail/detail.php?d1id=6&dir_id=612&docid=779118&qb=saTB1sfQu/2/7rW/&enc=euc-kr&section=kin&rank=10&sort=0&spq=0

Student’s Day (September 20, 2009). Dusan Encyber. Retrieved on September 20, 2009 from http://100.naver.com/100.nhn?docid=759222

Position Paper # 11 Arthur C. Danto

1

Substantive and Analytical Philosophy



What is History indeed? Is it merely study of what happened in the past? Suppose that we know everything ever happened before and its detail, then could we say that we know History? The answer is obviously “no”. I am not insisting that knowing what happened in the past is not important. Rather, I would like to emphasize that History is something more than knowing about past.

Arthur C. Danto, in the first part of his book “Narration and Knowledge (1985)” tries to talk about two kinds of inquiry are covered by the expression ‘Philosophy of History’ as substantive and analytical philosophy of History. When he talks about substantive philosophy of History, he would like to sharply distinguish whole of History from whole of past. It is quite interesting topic for me as I study philosophy of History. Danto, in his book “Narration and Knowledge (1985)” supposes that we have Ideal Chronicle by which we know everything that ever happened. Then he says that even if we know all the events took place in the past, and we have ideally complete account of them, it is still not whole of History. Rather, it is good source or data for whole of History. (Danto 1985) Base on this theory, I would say that History is something more than knowing about past events.

Then, he suggests two distinct kinds of such theories, descriptive and explanatory. What he means by descriptive theory is simply which seeks to show a pattern amongst the events which make up the whole past. And explanatory theory refers to explaining of what descriptive theory has found. (Danto, 1985) I would agree with Danto insisting that those two kinds of theories must be connected to be qualified as a philosophy of History. It is quite obvious and simple idea. If we are to explain some Historical events, out explanation should be based on factual evidence and support of descriptive theory. And also description without explanation is just meaningless. I believe that studying History must contain both description and explanation.

However, Danto was actually opposite to substantive philosophy. For me some parts of substantive theory were agreeable that say about connection of descriptive and explanatory theory. But like Danto, I would have to disagree with substantive theory. And I find the error of substantive theory in Danto’s line explaining of it and I quote: “a truly successful Historical theory would go beyond the data gathered by History, not only reducing them to a pattern, but predicting, and explaining, all the events of future History. (Danto 1985) This line simply means that substantive Historians are trying to write the History of events before it they have happened. I think it is quite wild idea. I believe that God would tell us what will happen through His servant and we call it a prophecy and I actually believe in it. However, it seems to be so wild for me that we can make prediction of the event that will take place in the future based on our Historical understanding. Moreover, the problem is that substantive Historians also try to give an account of the past events based on the account of future.

So I would agree with Danto saying that our knowledge of the past is always limited by our ignorance of the future. (Danto, 1985) This is a main point of analytical philosophy of History proposed by Danto. Actually, some events are somehow predictable but indeed in general we do not know what will happen in the future.


2


Incomplete History


That is why History is incomplete. History cannot be completed at once or in one generation. True Historical understating actually comes later. The result that one’s act will bring is not known at that time but later. For instance, when Rosa Park refused to sit at the back of the bus, none of people in that bus knew that the incident in that bus would initiate the Civil Right movement in the United States.

Indeed, History is History because it is story of the past. What does it mean? History is that of future people. We cannot really consider our time as History right now but it will be History for our next generation. Therefore, the analysis of Historical event of Rosa Park does not belong to those who were in that bus but to people of the future from the time that event took place. People who come later are the one who can give significance of the event of Rosa Park which was starting point of Civil Right movement in the United States.

History is somehow process of present or future people to evaluate various past events. Consider that French people of 18th century did not really realize that they were making monumental civil movement for freedom. In fact, they were just hungry and angry at unjust king and his kingdom. It is their descendants who evaluate and consider the civil movement took place during 18th century as monumental. Likewise, this simple but obvious explanation on Historical understanding and evaluation could prove the error of substantive philosophy of History that I have stated above.

Those who come later have privilege to evaluate and give meaning to Historical events took place. And it is History indeed. That is why Ideal Chronicle is not really History but just sources of History.

So, if Ideal Chronicle is not complete History, and if we cannot explain Historical events with Ideal Chronicle, then how can we analyze and explain them? What form should Historical text take? Danto has the answer to these questions. The answer is “Narration”


3


Narration and Knowledge


According to Danto, History is simply a story of the past and the form of stories is always in narrative. I would have to agree with him because it is a general fact that most of Historians tell us stories.

Narrative form of stories actually has the ability that Ideal Chronicle does not have. This ability of narration is that it can tensed sentence. What does it mean? Narration enables Historian to speak of extended events by employing what Danto calls Project verb which is a certain range of our verbs of description of action refer to events which actually are not discrete at all. (Staloff, 1995)

Ideal Chronicle cannot say for instance, in September of 1939 the Second World War began because the declaration of the war came some time later. Likewise, Ideal Chronicle cannot give significance of certain event. What it can contain is just description of event happening in present tense.

As what I have stated above, giving of significance of certain event belongs to future people from the time that the event takes place. In other word, narration of Historical event belongs to future. That is the privilege of the people who come later.

Let us go back to the Second World War. Unlike Ideal Chronicle, narration can give significance of the Second World War by using project verbs. In narration, we can say like this: “In September of 1939, the Second World War which would be the most terrible fighting which has never happened before has begun. This war was intended by Hitler, the German leader who had ambition of conquest all of European continent.”

Truly, Ideal Chronicle cannot give us significance of the Second World War like specifically when it began, and what was the factor that caused it. The reason why narration of the people or let us say Historians, can give significance of the World War II is that they have knowledge of historical context of that time in terms of states of each of European nations and their relationship with one another etc. And they even know how it ended. So narration may use synthesis of Historical context in order to explain certain Historical event and of course it would be much better account of event than ideal chronicle whose ability is merely description of state of the events happening.

Some are saying that narration would distort and exaggerate events as it tries to make them dramatic, exciting and interesting. In fact, it is true that narrative form of Historical text sometimes loses its objectivity. However, I would say that what is good about narrative is that it can still give us significance and emphasis of certain events. Therefore, as long as narrative account does not get out of factual Historical context in order to be too dramatic, I would want to consider it as one of the best way in bringing account of Historical knowledge.
I wish and believe that what I argue above could give clear account of importance and value of narration in History. I strongly agree with Danto saying History is a story. Isn’t it that the word “History” itself tells us something? History is his story, a man’s story.



Sources:

Danto, A.C. (1985). Narration and knowledge. Columbia University.

Staloff, D. (1995) The search for a meaningful past philosophies, theories, and
interpretations [Audiobook]. The Teaching Company.

Braudel, F. (1982). On history. (S. Matthews, Trans.). University of Chicago. (Original
work published 1969).

Thursday, October 1, 2009

Monograph # 10 Carl Gustav Hempel

Industrial Revolution


Alvin Toffler tries to explain how human society and civilization has been developing by suggesting three waves- First (Agricultural), Second (Industrial) and Third (Digital) wave. A new wave changes existing stream of civilization and emerges usually in the form of revolution. Based on his idea I would say that it is quite important for us to study about those three waves which made a great impact on human history.

What I would like to discuss in this paper is the Second wave, the industrialization, which brought great change to societies and civilizations in the world by overthrowing agriculture-based system. With Hempel’s theory of cause and effect, I am going to point out what caused the industrial revolution (the effects) within Europe, specifically in Britain. It will be quite interesting to carefully examine the causes of the great wave, which is one of the most noticeable impacts on History.

According to Hempel, the occurrence of an event (E) is explained when a statement describing that event (Explanandum) is logically deduced from general laws (L) and conditions that preceded the event (C) (Explanans). A general law is a universal claim that is capable of being confirmed or refuted by suitable empirical evidence. (Philosophy of Natural Science, p. 50) This is represented in the schema shown below:



C1, C2, C3 … Cn
(Statement of antecedent condition)

L1, L2, L3 … Ln
(General laws)

↓

--------------------------------------
E
(Description of the event to be explained)


In order to explain the Industrial revolution in Great Britain during 18th century (E), I would like to state several causes which are from the fields of politics, economy, society, technology, diplomacy, and geography.

C1: Stability in politics brought by Puritan Revolution and Glorious Revolution during 17th century.
C2: Growth of labor population in the city resulted by enclosure movement
C3: Invention of Steam machine
C4: Natural and Financial resources from the colonies
C5: Location which is geographically suitable to trade with other nations
C6: Abundance in resources like coal and iron ore

The First cause (C1) was the stability in politics brought by Puritan revolution and Glorious Revolution. As Britain has gone through the changes in politics, the political system, which was too much King-centered, collapsed and the citizen-centered political system was established. This change has caused the political unrest to die down. This also influenced people to concentrate on economic development, invention of the things and new technologies.

The Second cause (C2) was the growth of labor population in the city, which resulted by enclosure movement. Enclosure movements is a process in many European countries by which commonly held or unoccupied lands or wastelands passed into private ownership.(Encarta, 2003). Under this process of agricultural revolution, the farmers who owned small area of lands were forced to submit their lands or to sell their lands with exorbitant price. These farmers went to the urban cities to get a job. It caused a great increase in population of cities and brought urbanization. According to Adam Smith, the productivity generally increases when the population increases.

The Third cause (C3) was the most important one in industrialization. It was the invention of steam engine. James Watt, a Scottish engineer, invented a steam engine, a mechanical device used to transfer energy to steam into mechanical energy for a variety of application, including propulsion and generating electricity. This has brought great improvement in productivity with efficient using of energy which enabled generating machines in factories.

The Forth cause (C4) was the natural and financial resources from the colonies. Since Britain defeated Spain on the sea in 1588 during Queen Elizabeth era, the number of British colonies greatly increased. Britain received, from its many overseas colonies, the profits from the British slave trade between Africa and the Caribbean, which helped fuel industrial investment. It has been pointed out, however, that slave trade and West Indian plantations provided only 5% of the British national income. (Wikipedia) And a number of British colonies also provided British market places where Britain could sell her goods.

The Fifth cause (C5) was the location with which they had a geographical advantage in trade with other nations. Britain was located in an open area since it was an island. This geographical feature provided great advantages in trading with other countries.

The Sixth cause (C6) was the abundance of resources within the territory. At that time, there was a development of machinery, which worked instead of man. In order to produce machines, iron and coal, which was used to generate machines, were needed. Great Britain was abundant in terms of those natural resources. Based on abundance in resources, Great Britain could build up more factories and machines, which are directly related to productivity. It also brought development of transportation. Constructing rail loads made it possible to travel anywhere in Britain in a short time and it enabled quick supply of goods and services.

Under those conditions (C) that I stated above, Industrial revolution (E) would take place in Britain. Those causes are connected to the effects by several general laws. I would state:

L1: Political stability enables people to engage in economic activities
L2: Growth of population means increase in labor power and increase in labor power brings improvement in productivity
L3: Efficiency in process of producing things brings improvement in productivity
L4: Large amount of capital and resources enables mass production and large- scale production and colonies can serve as a market place
L5: Development in transportation brings Smooth and quick transport of goods and services
L6: Abundant natural resources enable equipment


The main conditions or basis for industrialization to take place are from large amounts of capitals, the increase in labor power, the enhancement in transportation, the technological development, and the possession of market places. According to the general laws I stated above, those causes I have mentioned can make the best environment for industrial revolution (E) to take place.



Cause (C) → General Laws (L) → Effect (E)



Sources:

Hempel, C.G. (1942). The function of general laws in history. In The Journal of
Philosophy, 39, 35-48.

Marie Hughes Warrington (2009). 50 Key Thinker on History New York: Routlege

Enclosure movement Retrieved from Encarta (1993-2003) Microsoft Corporation

Industrialisation (September 25, 2009) In Wikipedia. The Free Encyclopedia Retrieved 21:59 September 25, 2009 from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Industrialization

Robert L. Heilbroner. The World Philosophers New York: Touchstone book

Position Paper # 10 Carl Gustav Hempel

1


Cause and Effect



It is not arguable that every event has its cause, and normally, the causes of events, which happens around us, can be understood by our common senses. Human beings in general have a tendency to seek hidden causes or factors behind events. We ask ‘why’ when something happens and we answer ‘because’ to a question about an event. It is also applied in history. We are studying not just what happened in the past but also the causes, factor, insight behind the events. When we say that we understand a certain event, it means that we understand not only the event itself but the causes, the factor that made the event happen. According to Collingwood, we, Historians, should not be satisfied only with the past events themselves but must go deeper and draw things behind the events.

Carl Gustav Hempel, a German positivist philosopher, tries to point out causation from each historical events and he also insists that general laws plays a vital role in explaining and substantiating the events. I quote: “General laws have quite analogous functions in history and in the natural sciences, that they form an indispensible instrument of historical research, and they even constitute the common basis of various procedures, which are often considered as characteristics of the social in contradiction to the natural sciences. (Hempel, 1942)

What are the general laws? The term General law is used in the field of science and that means according to Hempel, “the idea that the statement in question is actually well confirmed by the relevant evidence available. (Helmpel, 1942) And we may call this as ‘universal hypothesis’. Obviously, he tries to study history with scientific approach which requires empirical knowledge. He says that “in every case where an event of a specified kind C occurs at a certain place and time, an event of a specified kind E will occurs at a place and time which is related in a specified manner to the place and time of the occurrence of the first event. (Helmpel, 1942)

Actually, I do not like the scientific approach to history because I believe that there are many things that cannot be explained by scientific notions and laws. However, I would have to agree with Hempel in some parts. I cannot deny that there is a cause behind an effect. It is a very simple but absolute law of the world. The water boils when the temperature is at 100 . The effect that water boils will not occur unless the temperature rises up to 100 . Likewise, also in history there is a certain thing that causes a certain event and the most of causations are general and easy for us to understand. And general laws play an important role that connects cause and effect.

I have always opposed a scientific approach in history, but this time I would have to say that historians need a scientific mind and perspective in order for them to study history more profoundly. But it does not mean that every historical event can be explained by certain laws and formulas. I do not think every universal hypothesis fits to explain certain events.

There are things that can be generalized and explained by certain laws. For example, we all generally know that a revolution might occur when people are being starved and they are being oppressed by unjust authority. This general law, or let’s say common sense, helps us explain a revolution by suggesting the causation of a revolution. That is why Hempel insists that a general law gives us a big help in explaining or studying historical events.

However, we should not overlook the fact that there are events that cannot be explained by general laws all the time. We cannot always give a clear and obvious explanation about the causation of event. And there will now be what positivist call “Pseudo-explanation”


2


Pseudo Explanation


Based on metaphors rather than laws; they convey pictorial and emotional appeals instead of insight into factual connections; they substitute vague analogies and intuitive ‘plausibility’ for deduction from testable statements and are therefore unacceptable as scientific explanations. (Ibid., p. 234)


A Pseudo explanation is not really obvious and factual. This term is used by positivists when they criticize the explanations that are not scientifically obvious and clear. However, I believe that a pseudo explanation which is mocked by positivist is quite useful tool in explaining and interpreting history.

I have been arguing that there are many things that cannot be explained by certain laws or scientific explanations. This is the limit positivists face. Those events which are not describable with specific laws are used to be under the pseudo-explanation which suggests metaphors and vague analogies rather than factual insight.

This sort of explanation seems to be much similar with Collingwood’s ‘a priori imagination.’ A priori imagination, even though it must be based on historical context, is not obvious and factual. In fact, a priori imagination is quite probable and can give us certain teachings and insight behind the events. However, we cannot say it is absolutely factual all the time since it is more on vague analogies and plausibility. I do not deny that Collingwood’s a priori imagination is not really obvious compared to scientific explanation. But it can draw certain insights and teachings behind history which positivist can’t give.

For example, when we say about Michelangelo Buonarroti, a brilliant artist during Renaissance period, can we give clear scientific laws which can explain the causation of his creative works? Can we say about the event that he creates things could happen because of x% of y cause and y% of x cause?
I am not driving out Hempel’s idea from historical study. I strongly agree with his idea of cause and effect. And as a Historian, a trial to draw the cause of certain event is quite necessary. However, I believe that we cannot give a general law and a scientific law for all the events. Sometimes, we must use our priori imagination to understand and interpret certain historical events. And we cannot say that this kind of imagination is nothing but a guess at all because a priori imagination proposed by Collingwood must be containing proper and wealthy knowledge and understanding of historical context and human mind (because a priori imagination is mainly dealing with human reason). The imaginations based on strong foundation of knowledge and historical context are reliable.

Hemple’s trial to explain history by giving probability of causation which brings certain events is quite unfamiliar but interesting with me. However, I would say that it is quite impossible for us to give exact percentage of chance of an event happening because there are causes that we can’t realize and find out behind of the events. We cannot say that these x,y, and z are everything that caused the event. What we can do is only suggesting this certain event (cause) would have caused the event (effect) most.

I would take the method of studying history which synthesizes ideas of both Hempel and Collingwood. I believe that historians must be able to find out general laws which are acceptable to common sense and that connect a cause and effect. But at the same time, historians should not be always bound by demand of scientific and general laws for all the events. We may as well take a priori imagination which positivist considers as pseudo explanation to analyze and interpret the historical events that cannot be explained in scientific means.



Sources:

Collingwood, R. G. (1946). The idea of history. Oxford: Oxford University Press, Pp.
205-334 .

Marie Hughes Warrington (2009). 50 Key Thinker on History New York: Routlege

Hempel, C.G. (1942). The function of general laws in history. In The Journal of
Philosophy, 39, 35-48.